jump to navigation

Honey and Clover June 21, 2010

Posted by ayasawada in Anime, Manga, Rave.
Tags: , ,
trackback


I finished reading the tenth and final volume of Honey and Clover last week. Despite knowing how it turns out — the anime having followed the manga pretty closely — I was still in tears by the end. Honey and Clover remains one of the most lovely, most profound, most perfectly paced, elegantly drawn, wonderfully nuanced series out there and a real jewel in the shojo genre.

There are a lot of very general things I could go on about: Chica Umino’s fabulous art, from the detailed close-ups in emotional moments to the cute SD in slapstick scenes, the comedy timing, the hard-hitting drama, the incredibly well-rounded characters — not to mention Umino’s lovely little ‘notes from the author’ in the margins (I always love it when an author adds these personal notes — it really gives a feel for who the person telling the story is. I’ve only ever seen it in shojo manga though. Does it happen in any other genre?).

But what really got me about Honey and Clover is the incredible empathy I felt for the characters and their emotional situations. From Umino’s side strips, you’d think she was typical otaku who knows nothing of real life romantic drama. Yet she writes them so well and with an aching, often bittersweet truth.

I was reminded of this reading the final volume as I bookmarked several pages, despite the fact that the main story takes up just half of the book itself. Some quotes:

Mayama: For some people, life means nothing without love. And for other people, whether they like it or not seem to be born with something they’ve got to do, like that’s what their life is for. I’m not saying one’s better than the other. And you probably don’t know which you are until the moment you have to choose, and then you just have to let your instincts choose for you.

Takemoto: I’ve been wondering for a long time if love that never bears fruit means anything. If something that vanishes and is gone is the same as something that never was.

Takemoto: As time passes I guess the day will come that all of this is just a memory. But… that whole miraculous time in my life is going to keep turning nostalgically somewhere far away deep in my heart, accompanied by a sweet pain forever.

Just thinking about it wells me up ^^; For a hopeless, confused romantic like me, it’s disarming to have someone quote your own thoughts at you, to offer advice and wisdom on love and life, friendship, work, family, ambition and dreams.

What I love about Honey and Clover is that things didn’t work out the way you’d expect. (SPOILERS) Hagu chose neither Takemoto nor Morita (and her final choice still has me going WTF, but it’s an understandable and mature one). Mayama and Yamada didn’t get together, though both found love.

Those love triangles tore those friends apart and yet they remained friends. And though life inevitably meant that they parted ways, they happily took those memories with them. What Honey and Clover reminds me is that life is full of really hard choices, but they are what makes you who you are.

The final volume comes with two bonus chapters that are excellent value, and a couple of really sweet short stories that show the same mix of imagination and mature views on love that you’d expect from Umino-sensei. And the ending itself goes a little beyond what is in the anime. You really want to experience both manga and anime to get the full experience, for what the manga adds in depth, the anime adds in atmosphere.

To anyone who hasn’t experienced Honey and Clover before, I’d shove the books into your hands right now. Then I’d make you watch the anime, then read the manga again. It really is one of the most lovely experiences you can ever experience in anime and manga, if not romantic literature.

Advertisements

Comments»

1. Japan trip 2011 « Canned Memory - July 3, 2011

[…] Osaka city, Odaiba and beyond. And my mind wandered to the line at the end of Chica Umino’s Honey and Clover: That whole miraculous time in my life is going to keep turning, nostalgically, somewhere far away, […]

2. Japan 2011 – the otaku’s tale « Canned Memory - July 4, 2011

[…] My favourite random library, however, was the one that opened for two hours in the middle of the four hour ferry ride from Kagoshima to Yakushima. I have fond memories of staring out to sea and bringing myself to tears by re-reading the end of Honey and Clover. […]

3. Yokohama | Canned Memory - August 26, 2013

[…] any particular reason other than its prominence in numerous Japanese media (a famous chapter in Honey and Clover for instance). Well, okay, maybe this time for one particular […]

4. Christal - November 2, 2015

Hi everybody, here every one is sharing such experience, so it’s golod to read this blog, and I used to pay
a visit this web site daily.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: